Author Topic: I know this might be blasphmey here but how does a Phelps differ from Star ?  (Read 4145 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

M21

  • Posts: 1
    • View Profile
As the subject says I have recently gotten a Phelps Loader and want to up grade with a case feeder, and find out the differences. Hopefully I won't get struck by lightning by posting this here.

Thanks
John

rbwillnj

  • Global Moderator
  • ****
  • Posts: 1124
    • View Profile
    • Star Machine Works
Oh I don't think you will get struck by Lightning for asking that question,  I'm sure there are plenty of Phelps users who visit the forum.   By the way, Welcome to the forum.

I have had four Phelps reloaders pass through my hands.  Of the various Star copies, the Phelps is the truest.  Nearly every part on a Phelps is interchangeable with a Star, and except for the resale price, the differences are mostly cosmetic (and I say this as a devout Star user).   

Phelps made a number small design changes in an effort to reduce machining costs.  Of the four Phelps I have owned, no two were exactly alike, but the changes were not material to the function of the machine.   Phelps made his dies on a screw machine, and the dies don't have the same quality machined appearance as Star Dies, but I haven't loaded enough rounds on a Phelps to say there is any difference in how the dies function.   Phelps also made his own carbide sizing dies.  As to the quality of the Phelps reloaders, I would say they are very close to the Stars, but some that I have owned were maybe not quite as tight as the Stars I have owned.   Whether this was due to manufacturing tolerances or ware, I can't say for sure.

Phelps reloaders typically sell for 1/2 to 2/3rds to price of a Star in comparable condition.
Star Machine Works
NRA Patron Member

Kenneth L. Walters

  • Active Members
  • ***
  • Posts: 199
    • View Profile
The Phelps rifle unit had a manually operated powder measure, at least on the one I knew about.
former progressive press collector

 

anything